Woman going to court to fight 'unfair' parking fine appeals for other victims in Milton Keynes to come forward

A driver who is convinced her parking fine was unfairly issued at MK city centre is appealing for other victims to help her fight the matter through the courts.

Penelope Lunn has been battling in vain for the past two and a half years to get the fine lifted and is now about to enter the final stage – appearing before magistrates to plead her case in court.

She has vowed to take a stand against all hard-hitting parking companies, saying: "It’s the principal.”

And she is urging anyone who has suffered a similar experience to get in touch to add weight to her case.

Has anyone in MK successfully  battled a parking fine through the courts?placeholder image
Has anyone in MK successfully battled a parking fine through the courts?

Penelope’s ticket was issued by multi-million pound company Smart Parking at MK Central train station, where she had parked for an hour for a Universal Credit appointment at nearby Phoenix House.

She had tried in vain to pay on the company’s phone line, only to find the final step – saying yes to the transaction – repeatedly failed to be recognised.

"I tried the other option of manually typing the number 1 for yes, but there was still no completion,” she said.

Worried she’d be late for her appointment, Penelope went into Phoenix House. She emerged 20 minutes later and once more tried to pay, only for the same thing to happen.

"With no other means of payment I went home to pay retrospectively on their website, but that was not an option,” she said.

When a parking ticket arrived, Penelope tried to appeal. But her repeated attempts were refused, she said.

"Smart Parking claim no one else has had this problem so they won't accept fault,” she said.

“I have the same car, phone and debit card and no problem with anyone else. There were plenty of funds in my bank and I provided screenshots of call records to prove I had been on phone to them twice during the parking time.

“I am more than happy to pay a pound but numerous debt collection threats over the years have only fallen on deaf ears, like the other disgruntled unhappy people on Trustpilot.”

Penelope has now submitted a subject access request FOI to Smart Parking Ltd and is due to appear in court in a few weeks’ time.

She is specifically looking for anyone else who has experienced the same non-confirmation of payment issue to support her case.

“Has anyone else actually gone to court?” she said. “They all seem to cave at the debt collection threat letters and pay up. But I’m not going to.”

In August 2024, James 'Jim' Hibbert, an 85-year-old from Greater Manchester represented himself to win a David v Goliath showdown against Smart Parking in court.

He had Middleton Shopping Centre in November 2022 and paid the 50p charge in three 20p coins, unbothered about the 10p change.

However, a Parking Charge Notice (PCN) came through his door a month later, fining him because he’d paid an “insufficient amount”.

After Jim’s appeals were refused by the company, he spent two years preparing his case for court and emerged victorious. Smart Parking Ltd was left with a legal bill for thousands of pounds.

.

News you can trust since 1981
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice