Here's how we rated the players at the Kassam Stadium.
1. Lee Nicholls - 5
Was almost caught out on a couple of occasions with some loose passes, while will have to shoulder the blame for his indecisiveness leading to Oxford's second
2. George Williams - 6
Saved Dons from further embarrassment with an excellent goal-line clearance in the second half. The most reliable of the back three on the night.
3. Dean Lewington - 5
Looked unusually unsure on the ball and had his lack of pace exposed by a rapid Matty Taylor.
4. Baily Cargill - 5
Struggled to come back from Oxford's early opener, which he should have done better with.