Bosses disagree over penalty decisions in Dons’ draw with Mansfield

A tale of two, or perhaps three, penalties at the One Call Stadium

Both MK Dons and Mansfield Town could have been awarded penalties during the 1-1 draw at the One Call Stadium on Saturday, but neither did, and neither head coach could agree on whether that was right or not.

Stags boss Nigel Clough believed his side could have had two spot-kicks, but referee Emily Heaslip refused to point to the spot on either. The latter, an incident involving Luke Bolton, looked so nailed-on that Dons head coach Paul Warne even went over to Clough to apologise for not getting the rub of the green, only to be told by his analysts later that it was a dive.

Welsh international Aaron Collins was then denied a penalty when he appeared to be pulled down - more of a stonewall case in Warne’s mind.

“My analyst said (Collins) was pulled down but the Mansfield player has dived,” he explained. “I cursed because I thought he dangled a leg out there and it was definitely a penalty and definitely a defeat. My head went to worst case scenarios, but then I heard the crowd roaring.

“I even went over to their manager to apologise because it looked so much like a pen, but my analyst said it definitely wasn’t. No-one really went mental, and you always go off the players’ reactions. You can usually tell by the validity of their appeals. On another day, if the ref gives that and we lose unfairly, that’s difficult to swallow.”

Clough meanwhile said: “We thought we had two good penalty appeals and on another day they both could have been given. For neither of them to have been given is unusual and disappointing.

“Nathan (Moriah-Welsh) is just going to tap it in and their lad had just slid through and taken him out.

“Luke Bolton has gone down and nothing is given. Paul Warne came over straight away and said it was a penalty all day long.”

The Stags boss also felt his side did more than enough to win the game, despite being denied by Callum Paterson’s fifth goal of the season ten minutes from time to share the spoils.

“We should have won. We played well enough at 1-0 up at the start of the second half with the chances we created,” he said. “We played some very good stuff and got into some good situations. We had three or four good situations in the first half without making the most of them.

“Jon Russell had a great chance at the end and then blazed over. We have got to start putting chances away, there are too many good chances being wasted.

“They could have nicked it at the end but over the course of the game we played well and would have got out of sight with better finishing.”

News you can trust since 1981
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice